The Times and Tides of Ocean City, Maryland
   HOME CONTACT US SHARE THIS PAGE  SOCIALIZE WITH US FaceBook YouTube Ocean City Life-Saving Station Museum
Ocean City, Maryland Then & Now - Lot 45
Part One: 1875 – 1917
by Gordon Katz

This is the only available view of the house on lot 45, circa 1907. The large building in the foreground left of center with the dormers is the Seaside Hotel. The porch facing Wicomico Street and the roofline of the house are visible just above the roof of the hotel. The neighboring buildings originally erected by Charles Gallagher can be seen to the left of the house in this picture.
Lot 45, located on the southeast corner of Baltimore Avenue and Wicomico Street, sits in the heart of downtown Ocean City. The lot has a frontage of eighty feet on the east side of Baltimore Avenue and a depth of fifty feet along the south side of Wicomico Street. It was among the very first properties in the new resort to be developed after the Atlantic Hotel opened on July 4, 1875. The latest establishment to make its home there, a restaurant and bar called “The Pour House”, only dates to May 2011. There have been many others who have taken their turn in years past. Here is a look back at a bit of the history of lot 45.
Dr. Hillary R. Pitts from Berlin drew lot 45 at the stockholders’ meeting held at the Atlantic Hotel on August 31, 1875. At the time, Dr. Pitts was the president of both the Atlantic Hotel Company and the Wicomico & Pocomoke Railroad. He and the other stockholders who had drawn or purchased the lots along the south side of Wicomico Street had all improved their properties by 1877. The rapid development of those lots isn’t surprising, in that the area was the focal point of activity in the youthful days of Ocean City. On the north side of Wicomico Street stood the Atlantic Hotel, occupying most of an entire city block and bustling with summertime visitors. The train depot, through which hundreds or occasionally thousands of passengers came and went each day during the season, sat on the western edge of the hotel’s property. Across Baltimore Avenue from the Atlantic Hotel, Samuel J. Massey had opened the Seaside Hotel in 1877.
The early Wicomico Street developers included John B. Myers, Jr., a wealthy Philadelphian and the husband of Lemuel Showell’s sister Mary Ellen, who built a handsome house that took up the two lots closest to Atlantic Avenue (now the Boardwalk) plus a third lot on Atlantic Avenue. Next door to Myers, another Philadelphian and Atlantic Hotel Company stockholder, liquor merchant Charles Gallagher, had purchased the two lots on Wicomico Street originally drawn by James B. Dirickson and Zadock P. Henry, Jr. Gallagher opened a store where he peddled, among other merchandise, his company’s Gallagher & Burton brand of whiskey. Dr. Pitts erected his own cottage on the corner lot at Baltimore Avenue, a two-story structure with a wrap-around porch that faced both Baltimore Avenue and Wicomico Street.
It isn’t known for certain if the Pitts cottage housed a commercial enterprise, which seems likely given its location, or if it was simply used as a private residence. After Dr. Pitts died in 1887, his son John subdivided lot 45. In 1891 he sold the northerly part, thirty-eight feet wide and fifty feet deep, along with the house, to two brothers, George W. Henry of Baltimore and James P. Henry from Berlin, for $730. He sold the remaining undeveloped southerly part in 1892 to Ida K. Aydelotte, from Philadelphia, for $100.
George and James Henry were the sons of Robert J. Henry, the superintendent of the Wicomico & Pocomoke Railroad and a tireless promoter of Ocean City until his death in 1893. It was said that “every person who visited Ocean City and remained there a few days became acquainted with Mr. Henry”. George Henry was a druggist who had moved to Baltimore in the late 1880s to take the position of chief clerk of the Maryland Penitentiary. What his older brother James did for a living is unknown.
George Henry acquired his brother’s interest in 1894. He mortgaged the property in 1897, but by late 1900 he was in default. A public sale was held on February 16, 1901 at which Berlin hotel keeper and real
estate speculator Thomas T. Savage entered the high bid of $660. Less than three months later, Savage sold the house and land to William Taber for $1,150.
William Taber was the oldest of the surviving children of Stephen Taber, the Long Island businessman who had owned more than two thousand acres on Sinepuxent Beach and the mainland when he died in 1886. William was the only Taber family member to remain a property owner in Ocean City after the bulk of his late father’s vast holdings in Worcester County were sold off in 1890. He and his wife Sarah had earlier acquired Charles Gallagher’s two lots and store on Wicomico Street in 1891, and the Myers property on the corner of Wicomico Street and the Boardwalk in 1898. The couple had also built a large house on the beach between South 2nd and South 3rd Streets in 1897 that was admired for its expensive furnishings. The house was destroyed by a storm in October 1903. The Tabers rented out their properties, other than the beach house, to commercial tenants. One of the later tenants was Rudolph Dolle, who opened his well-known caramel popcorn and salt water taffy stand in the former Myers house in 1910.
William and Sarah Taber sold their portion of lot 45 to two brothers from Baltimore, Adolf and Ralph Michelson, for $2,500 in 1907, taking back a mortgage of $2,000. The Michelson family had emigrated from Russia to the burgeoning Jewish community in Baltimore in 1890 when the two boys were quite young. Adolf was a printer by trade and his younger brother Ralph ran a confectionery store. The pair had decided to try their hand as retailers in Ocean City, but unfortunately their timing wasn’t good. As of April 1, 1908, all of Worcester County, including Ocean City, went “dry”. For a time afterward, summer crowds and real estate values suffered as a result. The brothers gave up their venture after the 1910 season, and in early 1911 they conveyed the property back to the Tabers in exchange for the cancellation of the unpaid balance of their mortgage.
Levi (L. Wallace) Purnell, a real estate investor from Snow Hill, bought the house and lot from the Tabers in May 1911 for $1,475. Purnell died shortly thereafter, and his children Mary E. and Matthew Purnell sold it to Daniel and Margaret Trimper in July 1914 for $1,200. After renting the building for several years, the Trimpers turned the deed over to their oldest grandchild, Daniel Henry Gordon, on October 23, 1917.
Daniel Henry Gordon was the son of Daniel and Margaret Trimper’s daughter Maggie and her first husband, William Gordon. Maggie was already pregnant with her son when she and the rest of the Trimper family moved from Baltimore to Ocean City in early February 1893. She gave birth to the boy she named Daniel Henry on October 21, 1893. He was given the nickname “Goldie” early on (he was actually listed by that name in the 1910 census) because of his blond hair and to avoid confusing him with his grandfather.
Gordon had previously purchased the southerly part of lot 45 from Ida and Steven Aydelotte in July 1913 for $500. The deed doesn’t identify any specific improvements made by the Aydelottes in the more than twenty years that they owned the lot, and the purchase price indicates that if any had been made, they weren’t of much value. When his grandparents gave Daniel Henry Gordon the northerly part of the property in 1917, ownership of lot 45 was once again held by one person.
Part Two: 1917 to the Present will appear in the next edition of Scuttlebutt.

<<<<   Previous Entry: Ocean City, Maryland - Then & Now Lot 45 Part Two OPEN PRINT VERSION RETURN TO MAIN MENU Next Entry: Ocean City, Maryland Then & Now - Lot 9, The Major Part Of Lot 10 & The Easterly 1/2 Of Lot 25   >>>>